Grarrrgh, cliffhangerrrrrrrrr. I hate cliffhangers. I like my books to have an end, even if it’s one that leaves a million questions to be answered by the next book. Not only is it polite to give readers an ending, it makes it easier for this particular reader to, you know, remember what happened when it comes time to read the next one! It’s only been a couple weeks since I finished the book and it’s already leaving me…
Which is really unfortunate because this book was otherwise fantastic! It begins pretty soon after the end of the last book, which saw our intrepid child artists alternately fleeing and fighting bad guys and demons using crazy art magic. Now Matt and Em are stuck inside their grandfather’s castle, safe but bored out of their skulls — well, until they inadvertently figure out a way to be neither of those.
See, it turns out that in addition to being able to animate things that they paint and speak telepathically, the twins can also — wait for it — time travel via painting. Because of course they can. On the plus side, this helps them find their missing mother; on the minus side, they find themselves in the middle of an epic battle eight hundred years ago that it is possible they may have started. Dun DUN.
I loved this book for all the reasons I loved Hollow Earth, plus reasons like time travel (yay!) and characters making very terrible decisions (yay?). I am still surprised by the realistic interactions between the kids and their respective lower-case guardians, in which the kids listen to the adults exactly as much as they think they need to, and the adults understand that the kids are still going to go do incredibly stupid things but are willing to let them make mistakes. This approach does not always work out for the best, but does any, really?
I am also very intrigued by the dun DUN parts toward the end of the story that lead into the dreaded cliffhanger, and am curious to see how the Barrowmans are going to get everyone out of this one in the appropriate number of pieces. They will, right? This is a series for kids. It’s going to be okay. I think. When does the next book come out?!
Recommendation: If you can stand it, wait to read this one until the next one comes out, someday. Otherwise, read it now!